Cochiaro’s Pizza

Reviews

• Smile_always 1.

  star star star star star 14 July 2026

  Went here a couple months ago, it was good pizza for a good price. Their Italian beef is worth trying. I can tell that their staff works very hard to clean and

• Jennifer P.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 9 July 2026

  Consistently their pizza quality has decreased over the years, but they continue to raise prices month after month.  Ice cream cones were $.99 at the beginning of the month, now $1.25 but more shockingly, even with a coupon for a special we usually order (2-14" pizzas and come=15.96) they refused to honor it despite there not being an expiration date.  He said it would now be $18.99 and that he could not make any price adjustments in the computer(which is a complete lie). The person taking my order said that the coupon CODE I gave matched an $18.99 deal but found newer coupons and the coupon code was completely different. After living in this neighborhood my entire life (my parents and grandparents as well), it's sad Cochairos has now become a last resort option for Pizza nights.
  
  Update: they were doing good for a few months but now their staff is back to space cases.  1) I spoke to the owners son probably 5+ months ago about how a delivery driver was speeding 20+ over the 30 mph speed limit and then cut through the turn lane at Wolf and Diversey only to blow the red light so he could make it back for another delivery. Nothing was done, the driver is still delivering for the business.
  2) Today I ordered for half price Monday. I ordered a 20" half sausage half bacon for PICK UP.  The total was OVER what it should have been. I asked the girl taking my order why it was more expensive. It should've been around $11.50. She insisted that it was bc they charge for both toppings even thought it was only HALF toppings on each side. I told her no that's not right she insisted to say "it's always been that way". It certainly never has "Been that way" since I was a kid so prices went up again but nice attitude. Ha. Cool thing but it was still too expensive. Sure enough I get to the store 30 minutes later and my sister is calling me "there's a delivery driver here from Cochiaro's". Turns out the cashier charged me extra for DELIVERY and I had to wait for them to sort out the issue while my sister apologized to the driver. This particular driver has always been sweet! I feel so bad for him. I hope you guys still gave him a delivery fee bc it was your screw up and now he lost out on $$$! Maybe even get your cashiers to pay attention to what they're doing! My pizza was slid in all the commotion from the in and out of the car 2x. Wasn't too bad and ate the pizza anyway.

• Jorgie P.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 8 July 2026

  Worst place I've been too EVER!! My boyfriend got a combo beef sandwich extra dipped and he got it dry as the desert and the beef tastes soo rubbery, not the mention it was very pricey. The hot dog wasn't really Chicago style and that also tasted rubbery. The rib tip dinner tastes like the ribs had been sitting out  all day. They were dry with no flavor. Don't get me started on the 2 girls that waited on us. One kept giving us looks like we were stupid and the other just wasn't present when trying to give our order. The only good person there was the young gentlemen answering phones. These 2 girls acted like they couldn't be bothered so all this is why we will not be going to this place again. Horrible service and horrible food. Maybe if they switch up and get some good food I'll reconsider but for right now this place will no longer be getting my money.

• Karen G.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 4 July 2026

  Worst service ever ordered a pizza at 7:15 told it would be here within the hour... called at 8:20 and told we are really busy it will be there in 20 minutes it's just now leaving!!!!! CANCELED!!! You should have called me letting me know I wouldn't eat dinner on a Thursday night till 9pm!!!
  
  Ridiculous not even sorry they couldn't care less and don't even deserve a one star!!!!

• Solomon T.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 29 June 2026

  I will never visit, dine or go there, bit into slice pizza n broke a tooth, after that I smelled it more, tobacco, shitty taste I gagged me